Understanding and engaging with our stakeholders
The Board continues to value and recognise the importance of engagement and cooperation with our stakeholders. Time is dedicated to listening to different stakeholder views and our commitment to stakeholder engagement is built upon the understanding that knowledge-sharing, widening of experiences and adopting a learner mindset will help us achieve our commercial, environmental and social objectives.
The Board remains grateful for the engagement opportunities it has had, including the 2023 AGM.
The Directors have continued to consider stakeholders' views in Board discussions and decision-making, as described in the "Section 172(1) statement" section.
Engagement with our stakeholders also goes beyond the Board and is continuous. Our broader businesses regularly engage with stakeholders throughout the year, and in the build-up to or during many Shell projects, activities, acquisitions and divestments. This engagement is often governed by formulated policies, control frameworks, regulation and legislation. It may differ by region.
Site visits
The Chair, certain Board committees and Non-executive Directors traditionally visit several Shell operations and overseas offices in a given calendar year. The objective of these visits is to provide the Directors with local context and deepen their understanding in the following ways, where relevant:
- provide insights into asset operations and portfolio positions;
- opportunity to engage directly with stakeholders, including staff, business partners, communities;
- improve the Board's oversight of top risks; and
- assess the Company's culture first-hand.
Visits provide a good opportunity for Board members to engage with each other and, in 2023 in particular, with three new Board members, the visits formed an important part of their induction.
Shareholders
The Chair, the Deputy Chair, the CEO, the CFO and the Executive Vice President Investor Relations each meet regularly with major shareholders and report the views of such shareholders to the Board. Committee chairs also seek engagement with shareholders on significant matters related to their areas of responsibility. During the year, Sir Andrew Mackenzie, in his capacity as Chair, met with more than 50 major shareholders, including during four days of roadshows. A variety of topics were discussed with the Chair, including performance, capital discipline and simplification of Shell; governance and Board priorities; and the Company's role in the energy transition. In the early part of the year, the REMCO Chair met with over 25 shareholders and discussed 2022 pay outcomes and remuneration policy changes ahead of the 2023 AGM.
Shareholders can contact Shell directly via the "Contact us" section of the Shell website. This allows investors' questions to be directed to the appropriate Shell team that can assist. Shareholders are also able to make use of our automated question response tool. Investors can also access information via the frequently asked questions section of the Shell website.
The Shell website also provides contact details for our Registrar, Equiniti, shareholder queries, our media team, requests for copies of the Annual Report, and general customer enquiries.
The Company's Registrar operates an internet access facility for registered shareholders, providing details of their shareholdings. Facilities are also provided for shareholders to lodge proxy appointments electronically. The Corporate Nominee service, facilitated by Equiniti, provides a facility for investors to hold their shares in the Company in paperless form.
Shareholder engagement on AGM resolutions
At the 2023 AGM, shareholders voted on two climate-related resolutions: (i) Resolution 25, which was an advisory vote on Shell's Energy Transition Progress – shareholders showed strong endorsement, with 80% of shareholders who voted casting votes in favour of our progress; and (ii) Resolution 26, a shareholder resolution, submitted by an organisation called Follow This on behalf of a small group of shareholders. The resolution from Follow This was broadly unchanged from their 2022 submission, which was also rejected by shareholders, as its variations have been every year since first being submitted in 2016. The resolution urged Shell to align its medium-term carbon emissions reduction targets with the Paris Climate Agreement, including emissions from fuels burnt by consumers, known as Scope 3 emissions. We remain committed to constructive engagement with our shareholders, and we believe our climate targets are aligned with the more ambitious goal of the Paris Agreement. The Board believed the proposal from Follow This was not in the best interest of the Company and its shareholders as a whole. Resolution 26 received support from 20% of shareholders who voted. Shell is aware that some shareholders voted in support of both Resolutions 25 and 26, despite their conflicting content.
In 2023, the Chair, CEO and CFO hosted meetings with some of our large shareholders. These meetings covered many topics. We recognise and value the importance of stakeholder engagement when considering our energy transition progress. The Board is grateful for the time and contribution of all those stakeholders who provided feedback, and for the overall indications of support for Shell's strategy.
Following the AGM, we engaged with our largest shareholders offering further opportunities to discuss the progress made against Shell's energy transition strategy and to understand the reasons behind various voting decisions. The Chair subsequently had an opportunity to engage directly with our large institutional shareholders during his roadshow in September 2023.
These discussions showed that our large shareholders that did not vote in line with the Board recommendation on Resolution 25 and Resolution 26 were predominantly focused on Shell's energy transition strategy and not the 2022 progress, to which Resolution 25 related. Some shareholders continue to outline societal pressure influencing media coverage and expectations from beneficial owners as reasons for not aligning with the Board recommendation. Others raised questions related to medium-term targets, including a desire for a Scope 3 absolute emissions target.
This feedback was added to the ongoing internal considerations of the Company's climate targets, along with the outcome of the Dutch court case, the Powering Progress strategy, Capital Markets Day, and the commitments that Shell had made within its energy transition strategy.
Engagements in 2023
Information on engagements the Board has held during the year is summarised below. Information on engagement with other stakeholders including the workforce is provided in section "Workforce engagement". The way in which stakeholder interests were considered in principal decision-making by the Board in 2023 (Section 172 statement) can be found in "Section 172(1) statement". Further insight into our engagement with stakeholders can be found within our Sustainability Report, scheduled for publication in March 2024.
- Engagement before event
- Event/activity
- Director attendance
- Outcome/insight
Engagement before event
Engagement was undertaken before the meetings so that the Directors were provided with understanding and insight on particular topics of interest.
Event/activity
In March 2023, Neil Carson, Chair of the REMCO, presented the 2022 remuneration outcome and 2023 remuneration plans to investors. The presentation included summaries on:
- reflections on the Company's financial performance, portfolio and launch of the Powering Progress strategy;
- 2023 Remuneration Policy changes;
- changes of Directors and appointment terms of the new CEO;
- remuneration for 2023; and
- forward-looking agenda.
Director attendance
REMCO Chair
Outcome/insight
Shareholders were provided with context and an explanation of the REMCO deliberations in arriving at the 2022 pay outcomes and setting the pay framework for 2023 and had the opportunity to ask questions and provide feedback.
Engagement before event
Discussion with the Chair of the Board to ensure that key topics would be covered.
Event/activity
This annual engagement took place in March 2023 in London with investors. It included an update on ESG matters of significance, including Shell's 2022 Energy Transition Progress Report outlining the progress towards Shell's targets to become a net-zero emissions energy business by 2050.
Director attendance
CEO and CFO
Outcome/insight
Any questions requiring follow-up were addressed outside the presentations. In some cases, follow-up meetings were held with stakeholders and the Chair of the Board.
Engagement before event
Discussion with the Chair of the SUSCO on key topics for inclusion in the visit agenda.
Event/activity
The SUSCO and the Chair of the Board visited the Rheinland Energy and Chemicals Park in Germany in November 2023. The visit included a review of energy transition projects that are part of the site transformation, a review of operational safety and process safety performance, a tour of the facility, meetings with site staff, and an engagement with the Director General at the Ministry for Economic Affairs, Innovation, Digitalization and Energy of the state of North Rhine-Westphalia.
Director attendance
SUSCO and Chair
Outcome/insight
Greater insights into the ongoing operations and transformation under way at the Rheinland Energy and Chemicals Park.
Engagement before event
Directors engaged with investors ahead of the event on a number of matters, including those being voted on at the AGM.
Event/activity
As well as the Company giving a balanced report of results and progress at the AGM, shareholders had an opportunity to ask questions in person, via the digital AGM platform, telephone, or submit questions via the Q&A desk outside of the auditorium.
Director attendance
Board
Outcome/insight
A number of additional engagements including follow-up meetings and answering of queries.
Engagement before event
The Chair of the Board engaged with over 50 large institutional investors during roadshows in April and September 2023.
Event/activity
The Chair of the Board provided an update on the governance of Shell and gave key investors opportunities to ask questions. Key topics included governance, remuneration, energy transition and business outlook.
Director attendance
Chair
Outcome/insight
Provided the Chair with an opportunity to listen to key institutional shareholders and to provide Board perspective on topics such as governance, energy transition, business and management performance.
Engagement before event
Engagement prior to the visits helped to formulate the agenda and refine the areas of focus for the respective visits.
Event/activity
During 2023, the ARC conducted a site visit to the USA where it visited a number of operations, including Shell Polymers Monaca, the Shell Norco facility, the Shell-operated Vito floating production facility in the Gulf of Mexico (virtual visit from New Orleans) and the Houston trading floor.
Director attendance
ARC
Outcome/insight
These site visits deepen the ARC's understanding of the risks and opportunities arising as well as its understanding of how the Company's Powering Progress strategy is implemented.
Engagement before event
Discussions were held with the respective Directors ahead of the visit to formulate the agenda and encourage a natural, open dialogue in the group sessions.
Event/activity
In February 2023, the Chair of the Board visited the Shell Business Operations offices in Bangalore, to deepen his understanding of operations and meet staff.
In March 2023, one Director visited Nature Energy and met with operators of the plant, and also visited the office in Odesund meeting with the Nature Energy's CEO and CFO for an overview of the company.
In June 2023, the Chair of the Board visited NAM, Shell Energy and Chemicals Park Rotterdam and Shell Chemicals Park Moerdijk. The visit entailed staff engagement sessions in all three locations, and with the NL leadership team in The Hague. Additionally in June 2023, the Directors held their Strategy Days off site in Vancouver and visited LNG Canada, in Kitimat, where they saw the asset under construction, met with staff and engaged with local communities and authorities.
In October 2023, the Chair of the Board visited China and attended the Tsinghua University School of Economics and Management Advisory Board, the Shell Eco-marathon in Beijing, meetings with external stakeholders including a senior Chinese government delegation, and a staff engagement session.
At the start of January 2024, several Directors visited Oman and Qatar.
Director attendance
Directors
Outcome/insight
The Board gained an insight into the development and culture of the operations and maintenance teams. The use and impact of digitalisation tools were highlighted, and the future environmental capabilities of the site were discussed.